Link the service experience to your academic course content through deliberate and guided reflection.
The practice of reflection is what combines the learning to the service. We cannot assume that learning will automatically result from experience. If it did, we’d all be a lot wiser, wouldn’t we? Like us, our students may not learn from their experience. They may even learn the wrong thing or reinforce existing prejudices. Reflection helps prevent this from occurring.
Reflection can be in the form of journals, essays, class presentations, analytic papers, art work, drama, dialogue, or any other expressive act. The key to effectiveness is structure and direction. The nature and type of reflection determines it’s own outcome. An unstructured personal journal or group discussion is a great way to elicit effective disclosure. More specific academic outcomes will result from structuring these exercises with specific curriculum related questions. For example, a biology student might be directed to comment on ecological balance in her journal account of an exotic plant removal project at the Desert Botanical Gardens.
Written reflection is a productive approach that helps improve basic communication skills at the same time it leads to critical thinking about the academic focus of course objectives. It is the most common and the least intrusive in terms of taking up class time.
A more powerful, and in many ways more effective, approach is the purposeful dialogue or a class “Reflective Session.” This dialogue provides an opportunity for students to share experiences and exchange ideas and critical thoughts about the information being shared.
To achieve academic outcomes, the dialogue, while spirited and free, should be bounded by the learning objectives of the course. The faculty member must serve both as a facilitator to maintain the flow of ideas and a commentator who jumps on the relevant items and develops it into teachable moment.
This is not an easy task, but with practice the rewards are great. When we seem to be losing control, the process can be threatening, but it is often at these critical moments at the real learning occurs.
The real advantage of the group based reflective sessions over the independently written forms is its power to develop a sense of community, which is one of the general goals of Service-Learning. Whatever form of reflection is chosen, it is important to do it early in the experience to assure that students understand the process. It should then be followed up regularly to monitor their progress.
This type of deliberate and guided reflection is what leads to academic learning, improved service, and personal development. From the description of the learning cycle, we know that reflection is the key element in creating meaning.